"In the long term, Switzerland will need to recruit beyond neighboring countries"
Swiss companies attract young, highly skilled foreign workers, but many leave after just a few years. Alongside high salaries, helping their family members integrate can encourage them to stay, explains Mathias Lerch, former head of the Urban Demography Laboratory at EPFL.
Today, around 60 per cent of immigrants holding a B or C permit have a university education. This is revealed in a study published by EPFL and the University of Geneva, which analysed immigration data from 1966 to the present day. Most often, these individuals come from a country neighbouring Switzerland or, to a lesser extent, from another European Union country, and stay for between five and ten years. For Swiss companies, the challenge is to retain these employees as effectively as possible, at a time when the war for talent is set to intensify across Europe and when some countries are already stepping up incentives to bring their expatriates back home, explains Mathias Lerch, former head of the Urban Demography Laboratory at EPFL and co-author of the study.
How has the profile of immigrants to Switzerland changed over the past 60 years?
Mathias Lerch: The current situation is reminiscent of the 1960s, when immigration was also largely temporary and workers came mainly from neighboring countries. The main difference lies in education levels: back then, most foreign workers were relatively low-skilled. Their comparatively short stays were partly due to the seasonal worker system, although even many people with permanent residence permits stayed for only a few years, as their families remained in their home countries. By the late 1980s and throughout the 1990s, immigration patterns had changed. Migrants came from an increasingly diverse range of countries, and family reunification became more important. Immigrants began arriving with their families or bringing them over later, encouraging more permanent settlement in Switzerland.
Today, many foreign workers leave Switzerland after just a few years. Why is that?
Lerch: The typical immigrant to Switzerland today is 33 years old, highly skilled and has no children, with men slightly outnumbering women. For these individuals, a temporary stay in Switzerland may simply be a step in their career development or an opportunity to establish new economic and business connections that can be maintained after returning home. Others leave because they struggle to integrate into the labor market, facing unemployment or difficulties having their qualifications recognized in Switzerland. The extremely tight housing market, high cost of living and social isolation also continue to pose challenges for many immigrants.
How much do incentives such as tax breaks or support for starting a business, offered by countries such as Spain, Portugal and Lithuania to encourage their expatriates to return, affect Switzerland’s attractiveness?
Lerch: These measures may encourage more people to return home, but they will not necessarily reduce immigration to Switzerland. Spending time abroad can still be a valuable career experience and an advantage when returning to one’s home country. It is also worth noting that, for Swiss companies, this turnover in the workforce encourages fresh ideas and stimulates innovation. Switzerland nevertheless continues to offer significantly higher salaries than its neighboring countries, along with a high quality of life. It is also part of a larger, particularly dynamic cross-border economic area in Europe, encompassing southern Germany, northern Italy and the French border regions, which facilitates economic and business exchanges.
What can companies do to retain these foreign professionals?
Lerch: Measures that help family members settle in and integrate into Swiss society can make a company more attractive to these professionals, as can support in helping accompanying partners find employment. Some companies also provide temporary company housing to make settling in easier during the first few years. Highly skilled professionals in their thirties, without children and earning good salaries, may be able to afford housing in city centers on their own. However, such measures can be particularly helpful for young families looking to settle in Switzerland for the longer term.
Given future labor needs and the competition for talent that is likely to intensify across Europe, should companies start recruiting beyond neighboring countries or focus more on training their existing employees?
Lerch: Both approaches are worth pursuing. Internally, continuing education and training for employees is the ideal solution, but it will not be enough. The retirement of the baby boomer generation will create a gap that cannot be filled entirely by improving the skills and qualifications of the existing workforce. In the longer term, it may become necessary to expand recruitment beyond Switzerland’s neighboring countries. As Asian countries will themselves face labor shortages, certain regions of Africa may offer greater potential. North Africa’s Maghreb region and Nigeria, whose populations are projected to reach 400 million by 2050, could offer particularly promising opportunities, especially as access to higher education expands. However, accommodating these new migration flows will require society to adapt to greater linguistic and cultural diversity.
